Brilliant: The Evolution of Artificial Light Review
Close but not brilliant. Certainly, a good portion of the book is fascinating and illuminating. When Ms. Brox allows her voice to shine through, the book is swift paced and cogently written. But, too often, Ms. Brox included long quotations, and relied too heavily on others to tell her story. On too many occasions, I felt that I was reading a college paper with sentences such as "the author notes that" followed by a lengthy quotation. Ah, but for a good editor.... These lengthy quotes were distracting. But when Ms. Brox tells the story of the social history of light in her own words, the story shines bright and clear.
I understand that including photographic plates would make the book more expensive. But, I often found myself having to consult internet sources to see the kinds of devices that are described in the book. Perhaps, some drawings or photographic plates would have allowed the reader to see clearly these early contraptions that illuminated the homes of our ancestors. (I often wondered whether Ms. Brox actually viewed some of the instruments of illumination for herself, or was she relying on secondary sources to describe the device for her.) Perhaps, too, the author could have written about the nature, physics of light. For example, though there is much discussion of the AC versus DC current, there is hardly a sentence describing the difference. I understand this was not a book about the physics of light. But, for the laymen, it would have helped to understand the rudimentary nature of that thing that illuminates our world.
On the whole, this is an enjoyable read. The subject matter (tracing the use of artificial light from prehistoric times through the present) is quite fascinating. Putting aside some of the stylistic criticism, this is an excellent book. It is both enlightening and enjoyable.
Brilliant: The Evolution of Artificial Light Feature
- ISBN13: 9780547055275
- Condition: New
- Notes: BUY WITH CONFIDENCE, Over one million books sold! 98% Positive feedback. Compare our books, prices and service to the competition. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
Brilliant: The Evolution of Artificial Light Overview
Brilliant, reminiscent of Lewis Hyde's
The Gift in its reach and of Timothy Egan's
The Worst Hard Time in its haunting evocation of human lives, offers a sweeping view of a surprisingly revealing aspect of human history--from the stone lamps of the Pleistocene to the LEDs embedded in fabrics of the future. Brox plumbs the class implications of light--who had it, who didn't--through the many centuries when crude lamps and tallow candles constricted waking hours. She convincingly portrays the hell-bent pursuit of whale oil as the first time the human desire for light thrust us toward an environmental tipping point. Only decades later, gas street lights opened up the evening hours to leisure, which changed the ways we live and sleep and the world's ecosystems. Edison's "tiny strip of paper that a breath would blow away" produced a light that seemed to its users all but divorced from human effort or cost. And yet, as Brox's informative and hair-raising portrait of our current grid system shows, the cost is ever with us.
Brilliant is infused with human voices, startling insights, and--only a few years before it becomes illegal to sell most incandescent light bulbs in the United States--timely questions about how our future lives will be shaped by light.
Brilliant: The Evolution of Artificial Light Specifications
Amazon Best Books of the Month, July 2010: In
Brilliant: The Evolution of Artificial Light, Jane Brox illuminates the fascinating and forgotten history of man-made light, tracing its development through centuries of sputtering, smoking candles, to the gradual refinement of gas and, finally, electric light. Brox captures the sense of wonder that permeated the Chicago World's Fair as electric light lit up the "White City," and shows how quickly we became reliant on electric light, recounting the trepidation and anxiety that accompanied the mandatory blackouts of World War II and the power outages that have plagued New York City's power grid since the 1960s. Brox also addresses the unexpected consequences of light pollution, detailing the struggles of astronomers who are no longer able to see stars, and migrating birds that confusedly circle lit buildings at night until they die from exhaustion.
Brilliant is an eloquent account of how a luxury so quickly became a necessity, and permanently changed human history.
--Lynette Mong
Amazon Exclusive: A Letter from Jane Brox, Author of Brilliant: The Evolution of Artificial Light
Dear Amazon Readers,
So much of life as we know it--our long evening hours, our flexible working days, our feelings of safety at night--depends upon cheap, abundant light made possible by the incandescent bulb. Now that new government energy efficiency standards will make filament light bulbs illegal by 2014--and for the first time our new means of illumination may not be as satisfactory as the old--it's the perfect moment to look at the extraordinary story of how we came to inhabit our world built of light.
Just five hundred years ago almost everyone lived at the mercy of the dark. In a time before street lighting, travel at night was always perilous, and forbidden to all but a few. Most people were confined to their homes after sunset--authorities in some towns even locked citizens inside their houses for the night. Within their close quarters, many had no hope of more than a few hours of light in evening--meager, troublesome light cast by one or two stinking tallow candles or oil lamps.
Since then, each century of painstaking progress in illumination has had its own drama. The 18th century's need for more and more light spurred a world-wide hunt for whale oil, which proved to be so exhaustive it put the very survival of some whale species in peril, while the 19th century race to build a viable electric light involved the work of many scientists throughout Europe and America. In truth, Edison's bulb was not the isolated triumph it often seems to us now. His achievement was only possible after centuries of evolving understanding of electricity, and decades of experiments by dozens of scientists racing to fashion a workable incandescent light.
Edison's light assured cheap, abundant illumination for many, but not all. The democratic distribution of light in the United States depended upon the decades-long struggle by rural Americans to have the same access to electricity as those in the cities and suburbs. And controversies continue: as the demands for energy efficiency compete with our desires to have the light we want, we find ourselves in the midst of a new race for the perfect energy efficient light of the future. And as the grave consequences of light pollution become more and more evident we are faced with the question: How much light is too much?
When you read
Brilliant you'll not only gain insight into the history of artificial light, you'll find that the surprising, complex story of our illumination is also the story of our evolving modern selves.
-Jane Brox(Photo © Luc Demers)
Related Products
Customer Reviews
Information interesting; writing not so great - E. Jacobs -
This book is a topical history of artificial lighting from the early use of candles to current trends in electric lighting. It includes interesting information such as the roles and perceptions of early street lighting (will it encourage crime or deter it?) and the effect of artificial lighting on migration patterns in animals and sleep cycles in humans. I found the book to be a worthwhile read for this information alone.
The major problem in the book was the over-reliance on block quotes when the author could have easily paraphrased the material and referenced it. Instead, entire superfluous descriptions were cut-and-pasted into the text (though they were properly referenced). This led to major disruptions in flow, and I found myself skipping many of the quotes as they really weren't necessary to the overall story being told. I was always advised that any piece of writing should not be comprised of greater than 10-15% direct quotations. This book is a good example of why that is excellent advice.
Overall: 4 stars for information and 2 stars for writing. It's worth a read if you'd like a quick overview of lighting through history.
One of the best books I've ever read - Richard Crawford - Brigham City Utah
Having a voracious appetite for reading, I have found few books that I didn't like. This one fascinated me as I work with LED's, lasers, etc. I didn't realize it would go into such detailed history of lamps, candles, and every possible method of producing artificial light beginning thousands of years ago. There are so many instances of historical significance in this book, I just have to buy a copy for my History Teacher Son. I would consider it one of the most fascinating history texts available. The author has a wonderful ability to describe things in a way that you almost feel as though you had experienced it yourself. She makes even dull scientific data fascinating and interesting. I love books, I love reading. I have read books for sixty years. But this is easily one of the best books I have ever read.
Thank you Jane Brox for your marvelous masterpiece.
A Bright New Look At Life - Sacramento Book Review - Sacramento, CA
After reading //Brilliant//, you'll never take life for granted again. From the great blackout of 1965 to the many "brown-outs" of recent times, //Brilliant// illuminates the dark areas from the beginning of the Twentieth Century. The author, Jane Brox, has composed an enlightened look into the evolution of artificial light. The book is written in an easy reading style with lively language and interesting anecdotes that entertain as well as inform.
One of the most inviting prologues I have ever read lures you into the book. Brox covers it all, from the first lanterns at sea, to gas light and the emergence of the incandescent electric lamp. She remarks that during wartime some parts of Europe returned to old light. London endured a self-induced blackout to evade enemy bombardment. Even New York prepared itself to avoid becoming a target. All this makes us aware of how artificial light can cast an ugly shadow, and forces us to consider its use with care.
Reviewed by D. Wayne Dworsky
The Evolution of Artificial Light - Trenchant - Florida, USA
-
-
The SELLING potential of this GOOD book would increase fantastically by merely adding PICTURES
-
of the extremely RARE 'lighting' items referred to and partially described!
-
I blame this FAILURE on the advisors and/or EDITORS! Someone GOOFED!
-
Do a RE-CALL & REMAKE! And make a MILLION!
-
And give the 'Great' Physicist Nikola Tesla his rightful place among all those
-
'Invention Laboratory' helpers and tinkers! He "LIT UP THE WORLD"!
-
And, his :"FLUORESCENT" & "NEON" LIGHTS 'BLAZE' ceaselessly in Vegas, Reno, Atlantic City, and Times Square!
-
Without 'Tesla's "Alternating Current" (A/C) most people would still be using 'candles' and 'oil lamps' for 'LIGHT"!
-
-
I would like to add that coverage of F.D.R.'s Great "TVA" ,& "REA" Programs is exceptional; and the magnitude and far reaching beneficial effects are no doubt still being realized.
-
But these two superb demonstrations of the breadth of the 'genius' of Franklin Delano Roosevelt have not been given the respect they truly deserve; for they brightened the lives and futures of all those hundreds of thousands who for the first time ever were provided the use of "Electric Light" and "Power" from Nikola Tesla's Alternating Current!
-
-
*** Product Information and Prices Stored: Aug 28, 2010 23:52:05
