American Pastoral Review
Philip Roth is truly a unique and outstanding writer. It is somewhat of a travesty that he has yet to win the Nobel Prize For Literature.
I was really looking forward to American Pastoral which is the first Zuckerman novel that doesn't focus primarily on Nathan Zuckerman. It focuses on the seemingly charmed life of Seymour "Swede" Levov, a hero from Zuckerman's Newark. This novel won the Pulitzer Prize and is considered by many to be if not Roth's greatest novel then certainly one of the greatest.
For me, there are long periods of brillance in the story. Levov is living the American Dream. He is a tremendous athlete, a good person and a very successful businessman. For much of his life, he does not seem to have a misstep. He marries Miss New Jersey and they have a wonderful daughter.
Suddenly, the American Dream goes south as Levov's daughter is not the perfect All American girl. She turns into an overweight, angry girl with a stuttering problem. She is very, very angry about the Viet Nam War. Even though Swede is also against the war, she has disdain for his cozy, comfortable life. The Levov world falls apart when the daughter, Merry, bombs a local store, killing someone and then goes underground.
Swede Levov's pain and story is wonderfully told. Despite his daughter's crimes, he loves her and longs to save her. He is very nostalgiac about the perfect daughter of childhood. Despite dealing with the tragedy as well as he can, Swede never recovers. He has always had an accomodating character and done the right and sensible thing but the pain and sorrow eat him up inside.
Swede's brother, Jerry, is a perfect contrast in that he is outspoken, goes against the grain and lives life as he feels like it. His moments of telling Swede the way it is are very strong.
This is creative, heartwrenching and well written story of a perfect 1950s man lost and disoriented by the turmoil of the 60s. Roth describes the 60s in a very simplistic way intentionally as this is Swede Levov's perspective.
Again, I'll restate that American Pastoral has rich themes, typical Roth humour and interesting and unusual characters and situations.
Unfortunately several Amazon customers who have given negative reviews are correct in pointing out what I think is a significant flaw. The book really becomes tedious in points. Roth is extremely repetitive and looks at the same events from many different perspectives. This works for awhile but ultimately American Pastoral becomes a chore to read.
Roth is a wonderful writer and as much as it makes me feel like a Philistine, I have to say, he could have cut out 50 pages from this novel and it would have worked a lot better.
I definitely recommend it. Even if you find it tedious, there are lots of truly wonderful moments in the novel.
American Pastoral Overview
American Pastoral Specifications
Philip Roth's 22nd book takes a life-long view of the American experience in this thoughtful investigation of the century's most divisive and explosive of decades, the '60s. Returning again to the voice of his literary alter ego Nathan Zuckerman, Roth is at the top of his form. His prose is carefully controlled yet always fresh and intellectually subtle as he reconstructs the halcyon days, circa World War II, of Seymour "the Swede" Levov, a high school sports hero and all-around Great Guy who wants nothing more than to live in tranquillity. But as the Swede grows older and America crazier, history sweeps his family inexorably into its grip: His own daughter, Merry, commits an unpardonable act of "protest" against the Vietnam war that ultimately severs the Swede from any hope of happiness, family, or spiritual coherence.
Available at Amazon Check Price Now!
Related Products
- The Human Stain: A Novel American Trilogy (3)
- I Married a Communist
- Portnoy's Complaint
- Sabbath's Theater
- The Adventures of Augie March (Penguin Classics)
Customer Reviews
Overrated - FrenchText - New York, NY United States
I've read most of Philip Roth's novels but not in order of publication. I came to this one late and find it hard to understand why it received so much praise. The writing is overblown and pompous. The allegorical drive to make the characters stand for the underside and disillusionment of America in the 1960s means that the characters collapse under the weight of everything they're supposed to symbolize. All the female characters are monsters -- that's the word the narrator and characters use over and over again -- but not interesting monsters. And we learn far more than we need to do about the details of glove manufacturing. There are definitely some interesting ideas here, but the book never comes together as a fully realized, well-crafted novel. If you want to read mainstream Roth, I recommend giving this one a miss and reading THE PLOT AGAINST AMERICA, or better yet, pick up ZUCKERMAN UNBOUND, an unsung masterpiece.
American Pastoral - Esther B. Bates - Buffalo, NY
I am wading through this book because a book group to which I belong will be discussing it. The book is overly long and tedious, but you can't skip sections because you never know when a sentence or two will come along that finally moves the story forward. When Roth gets back to the story, rather than getting bogged down in details about the decline of Newark, about manufacturing gloves, and other side issues, the story is quite gripping and very upsetting. It it based on real events, but engenders little sympathy for the participants in the riots of the 60's & 70's and their families.
I think he had enough naterial for a long short story or perhaps a novelette, but insisted on stretching it out over 423 pages.
Ideas/Themes are there, poorly executed, poor standard for Pulitzer - EM -
Unbelievable that this would win a prize, let alone the Pulitzer. Quality in modern writing is just not there, I couldn't imagine such poor quality being published years ago.
The idea and theme were excellent and should have produced a wonderful novel. I found though this was poorly written, it was like the author didn't want to work at it and thought he could get away with it - at times it was rambling. Characters were poorly drawn, most notably Merry.
*** Product Information and Prices Stored: Aug 24, 2010 07:28:10
No comments:
Post a Comment